The Broken Lands (Review)

I actually finished this book several months ago.
The Broken Lands is a fictionalized account of what may have happened to the members of the doomed Arctic Expedition of Sir John Franklin. All in all it was an interesting book, if you are the type of person who likes the History channel or PBS documentaries.

Some may find the book to move intolerably slow
(I myself utilized it as a bedtime read and as such it took several months to digest) however there can be little doubt that the author Robert Edric did his research when writing this book. He provides excellent descriptions of the two ships, the HMS Erebus and the HMS Terror, as well as detailed descriptions of daily life and duty of crewmen on board 19th century British naval vessels.

Told in story form, it was necessary to not only advance the storyline through speculation but ultimately it was also necessary to develop the characters in a similar fashion, attributing sometimes less than auspicious personality traits to the names of men who no doubt retain traceable and living descendants to this day. That is to say that in order for Edric to advance the story, he was forced to speculate on the consequences of decisions that (may or may not) were made by officers who experienced varying levels of breakdown as isolation, starvation and the elements took their toll upon both the leadership and the crew.

Personally I was able to suspend my disbelief and indulge in Edric's speculations. In spite of what I wrote above and given that I am not a descendant of any of these men with the honor of an ancestor to protect, the speculations presented in the book regarding the fate of the crew seemed entirely plausible.

In the end it is an attempt to tell the tale of dead men.
And as we know, dead men tell no tales.